Casteist- Brahman is superior to Shudra.
Rational Hindu- How?
Casteist- Brahman came from mouth and Shudra came from leg at inception.
Rational Hindu- If Brahman came from mouth and Shudra from leg then:
1. Mouth produces saliva and remains dirty all the time. Leg, on the other hand is relatively purer, dry and odorless. So Shudras are purer than Brahmans.
2. We, in Hindu tradition, touch feet of our mother and elders. But we never touch their mouth or saliva! Many a times, we keep our head in their feet. It means, Brahman must bow down to Shudra in respect.
3. There is no proof of Brahman coming out from mouth and Shudra from leg. Every so-called Brahman possesses legs and not just head. Similarly every so-called Shudra possesses mouth and not just legs.
4. At inception? From where? Whose mouth and legs did Brahman and Shudra come from?
Casteist- I don’t have answers for 1,2 and 3. But we all came from Eeshvar’s head and legs.
Rational Hindu- Ok, is Eeshvar pure?
Casteist- Yes, absolutely.
Rational Hindu- Is any of His body-parts impure or inferior to the other?
Casteist- No no, he is uniformly pure and perfect.
Rational Hindu- So if His complete body is perfectly pure and equal, how does someone get inferior to the other just because the two came from equally pure mouth and legs of Eeshvar? Isn’t it that we all humans are Brahmans and Shudras at the same time?
Casteist- Don’t have the answer. I am defeated.
Rational Hindu- No, if you realize truth and equality, you are victorious.