A problem with RSS driven Hindutva intellectuals is that while their analysis of history and current affairs is solid, they are weak on foundations of Hindu Dharma. And because they have to include even Gandhi in Ekatmata Strotra and Nehru Baal Diwas in their schools, they confuse their cadre.
They would promote Nathuram Godse, Gandhi exposed, Nehru exposed via Panchajanya magazine, and then get embarrassed when their Pracharak makes Gandhi mascot of his Swaccha Bharat and other frivolous yet hugely marketed projects.
A typical RSS cadre does not know what to defend and what to oppose. Cow is symbol of Hinduism till 2016. Then their Pracharak turned PM speaks against Gorakshaks. And then their supremo sings glory of great PM. And now they have to change their narrative.
Aamir Khan is a villain till PK. But then Mohan Bhagwat decides to felicitate him in a function, and BJP government in Maharashtra makes him a brand ambassador, and suddenly narrative has to change.
The narrative on Vedas is utterly confusing because that was not focus. Somewhere they will prove Saraswati river in Vedas, and then get bowled over when confronted with Apaurusheya (eternal) status of Vedas that forms core of mainstream Hinduism. I found no RSS intellectual being able to address Jihadi and Christian propaganda because if they do, they will have to counter the narratives of their VIP pracharaks.
They wasted entire generations till 2014 shouting dangers of globalization and how Congress sold India to foreigners. And now when their Pracharak roams around seeking foreign investment, they have no courage to accept that they were fools to not understand Manmohan Singh’s vision, hyped on Swadeshi, and punished an entire generation to hate foreignism. And if they defend their acts of then, then they must slap their Pracharak of today who became a turncoat. Instead they praise him a hero.
Mother Teresa, Sanjay Dutt, Udit Raj, Ramdas Athawale, Goraksha and right to eat beef, Chaadars at Ajmer Sharif, Article 370 in Kashmir vs coalition with PDP, Party worker killings in Kerala and Bengal, Swadeshi, Aamir Khan, Ram Mandir vs Ram Museum Circuit, inducting professed Ram Mandir haters in party, Kashmiriyat, etc etc etc. RSS has become a saga of “shifting Hindutva” defined not by Krishna, Ram, Vedas, Gita but what Modi decides and Mohan Bhagwat claps for.
Despite being largest organization of Hindus that conducts largest number of training events in world, RSS remains a cadre of kho-kho players who do great service during natural calamities, but are totally ineffective in combating the intellectual and physical attacks because their Hindutva is hooked to political whims of their leaders. If you remove other Hindu organizations from scene, there will be zero resistance from Hindus against attacks except street marches in khakis.
A ground level RSS karyakarta is the best person you may meet in life. But as they evolve to higher roles, they have to adjust to inherent contradictions of neo-Hindutva of their leaders, and eventually end up being Kashmiriyat lovers like Rajnath Singh or Gorakshak haters. And those lower in hierarchy keep deluding themselves that it was a political masterstroke that none can understand, except them because they have Chanakya insight due to attendance in Bauddhiks.
Its time for a change. For getting back to basics – to Ram, Krishna, instead of some political pracharaks.
Q: Gaurakshaks are creating problems for legit businesses like ours as well in many places it is an extortion syndicate and trust me you won’t achieve anything without political force
That does not explain why PM of country should make 6 tweets and three different public speeches against them. His Mann ki Baat on Islamic terrorism, love jihad, death threats over Kamlesh Tiwari statement, killing of cow lovers etc etc is yet pending.
Even GST is creating problems for legit small businesses who are not tech savvy. Demonetization also created lots of problems for many. PM instead said, consider this to be a sacrifice for longer term solutions. Same for Goraksha. Or issue statements and tweets against GST and Demonetization
Q: I don’t agree with you on many points…Rigidness,Hate and taking law in hand is not supported by RSS…..watch videos of Dr.Mohan Bhagwat…it will help you
RSS is very flexible,connected with roots and with strong will power….PM Modi is no different
Ultimate goal of RSS is Akhand Bharat
A: Read Agniveer articles and posts. Watch Agniveer videos. It will help you and RSS. And help define what Akhand Bharat means. And understand what it takes to achieve it, beyond awarding Aamir khan
Q: Baseless analysis!
We knew it will burn those with night vision forced to be in sunlight. Trust us, it was deliberate, to make space for real Hindutva instead of political shifting game branded as Hindutva by night-vision specialists.