This article is also available in Hindi at http://agniveer.com/4982/polygamy-hinduism-hi/

Immediately after I published my analysis of Dr Zakir Naik’s views on Hinduism, I started receiving hate mails. However I also received a soft-copy of another book of his “Answers to Non-Muslims’ Common Questions about Islam”. This is another masterpiece of his sophism. I have already glimpsed through videos of his lectures where he recites this book line by line. Many rebuttals of this book are already available.

However what perturbed me, was another set of misconceptions he attempts to breed regarding Hinduism through his self-proclaimed research. I can understand why Dr Zakir Naik has to spend so much space discussing Hinduism in an article on Muslims, and so much space discussing Islam in an article on Hinduism (See in FAQ on Hinduism)! This apparent confusion emerges from the fact that in current political, social and cultural situation, 80 crore Hindus form the most ideal conversion ground for Islamic Research Foundation. Peace TV managed by Dr Zakir Naik even announced this a few months ago that they would make Hindustan a Darul-Islam in next 5 years.

Further, many Muslims believe in a prophecy that once India is conquered, only then would Jesus Christ come again and will bring end of the world. After that, Judgment Day would happen and they will go to Paradise to have their virgins and luxuries forever! The lure is too tempting for the uncultivated mind to drop all sense of reasoning!

In this article, I shall cover the first question he addresses – POLYGAMY.

Dr Zakir Naik has tried to prove that Hinduism is inherently a polygamous religion. He states on Page 4 of the book:
“The Qur’an is the only religious book, on the face of this earth, that contains the phrase ‘marry only one’. There is no other religious book that instructs men to have only one wife. In none of the other religious scriptures, whether it be the Vedas, the Ramayan, the Mahabharat, the Geeta, the Talmud or the Bible does one find a restriction on the number of wives. According to these scriptures one can marry as many as one wishes. It was only later, that the Hindu priests and the Christian Church restricted the number of wives to one.

Many Hindu religious personalities, according to their scriptures, had multiple wives. King Dashrat, the father of Rama, had more than one wife. Krishna had several wives.”

He continues giving some census data from sources best known to him alone that polygamy is more popular among Hindus than Muslims.

I shall not dwell into what Polygamy means in Islam of Zakir Naik – whether marrying 4 wives in total in entire life, or keeping the total number of existing wives at 4 by divorcing old ones as one marries new ones, or having special provision of 9/11/16/++ for those having revelations, or permitting marriage with babies, or whether keeping unlimited slaves and not counting them as legal wives and thus skewing census data. These issues have been dealt with by a large number of people including women-rights organizations, Muslim reformers and ex-Muslims worldwide. Internet lists a large number of such reference sources that you can google upon.


The focus of this article would be explode the myth that “according to Hindu scriptures one can marry as many as one wishes.”

POLYGAMY IN VEDAS
We start with the Vedas because Vedas are considered the foremost authority in matters of Dharma.
1. There is no single mantra in the entire 4 Vedas that even give a hint of supporting more than one wife or more than one husband.

2. Three mantras of Rig Veda, 1.124.7, 4.3.2 and 10.71.4 contain “Jaayeva Patya Ushatee Suvaasaah”. This means that knowledge comes to the scholar in same manner as a dedicated joyous wife comes only to her husband. “Jaaya” means wife and “Pati” means husband. Both appearing in singular implies that only one husband-one wife relation is considered ideal.

3. Rigveda 1.3.3 states that God is like a dedicated wife with high character and purity. This also implies that monogamy alone is considered ideal.

4. Rigveda 10.149.4 compares love between God and devotee like that between dedicated wife and husband. Both “Jaaya” meaning wife and “Patim” meaning husband are used in singular number implying strict monogamy.

5. Rigveda 10.85.20 appeals a bride to expand happiness for her husband. Again both husband and wife are referred in singular.

6. Rigveda 10.85.23 appeals to wife and husband to always have self-control. Its obvious from reference to self-control and singular numbers for both wife and husband that monogamy alone is recommended.

7. All mantras relating to marriage are addressed in dual number to a couple of husband-wife implying one wife for husband and one husband for wife. Some examples are Rig Veda 10.85.24, 10.85.42, 10.85.47 and almost entire 14th Chapter of Atharva Veda which deals with subject of marriage. Most mantras pray for faithful relation for entire life-time.
Please note that Sanskrit has a dual number apart from singular and plural, specifically to remove this confusion that people may have.

8. In Atharva Veda 7.35.4 both husband and wife state that, “You establish me in your heart so that our minds become one and same.”

9. In Atharva Veda 7.38.4, wife says that “You should only be mine. You should not even discuss about other women.” What can be a more clear prohibition of polygamy than this!

10. Atharva Ved 3.30.2 and 14.2.64 also appeal husband and wife to be devoted and faithful to each other.

11. Perhaps Veda provider Ishwar knew that despite all this, some self-proclaimed experts may still find reasons to justify polygamy. Thus certain mantras in Vedas describe demerits of Polygamy.

– Rig Veda 10.105.8 compares existence of multiple wives with multiple worldly miseries.

– Rig Veda 10.101.11 states that a man with two wives is pressed from both sides and weeps like a horse that neighs when pressed from both sides by spokes while driving a chariot.

– Rig Veda 10.101.11 state that two wives make life aimless.

– Atharva Veda 3.18.2 prays that may a woman never face threat of another co-wife.

12. The only mantra that skeptics try to give in favor of polygamy in Vedas is Rig Veda 8.19.36 that contains “Vadhoonaam” and “Satpati” words. However, “Vadhoo” does not mean bride here and instead means powers that provide happiness. “Satpati” means protector of good, just as “Bhoopati” means protector of earth. This is also evident from the Devata or Key subject of the Sukta in which this mantra comes – prayers for charity and donation (Daanastuti). The mantra means that Ishwar gives variety of powers to those who protect truth and good.

POLYGAMY IN RAMAYAN

While it is admitted that Dashrath practiced polygamy, but the essence of entire Ramayan is that polygamy leads to troubles. The polygamy of Dashrath is considered to be the cause of trouble and grief that everyone faced. Ram is considered “Maryada Purushottam” or the “Ideal Man” because he re-established the Vedic norm of monogamy. Same was followed by all his brothers.

POLYGAMY IN MAHABHARAT

By the time of Mahabharat, the moral values of society had declined a lot. Thus none of the characters, apart from Krishna, is considered exemplary in Mahabharat. And that is exactly the reason why Krishna has been targeted the most for character assassination by a variety of forces.

Mahabharat is an extremely adulterated text and is not taken as authentic in totality. The original text was much smaller and over a period of time it expanded to include a lot of things. Unlike Vedas, there was no mechanism to stop adulterations from it. However a close analysis easily exposes that certain popular stories in Mahabharat are pure myths. I give a list here:

First Principle

a. Krishna was wedded to none except Rukmini. The myth of 16000 wives came from a story where he liberated 16000 captive girls from Narkasur. The story itself is questionable. Further the story never states that Krishna married 16000 girls. It says he protected them, which is true if story is correct. had Krishna married 16000 of them, it would have taken him more than 10 years even at rate of 4 marriages a day as per the prevailing rituals!

b. Krishna was so strictly disciplined that he observed complete Brahmacharya for 12 years before planning to be a father. That is why Krishna is such a role model for entire society. The narrator of Geeta had no time for anything except nation-building in those testing periods.

c. Krishna never had any love-games with any Gopi. These are figments of imaginations which got popular during dark age of foreign rule when rulers of small states indulged in wasteful enjoyments after accepting supremacy of foreign rulers. Further the whole story of Radha is a figment of imagination. It exists only in Brahma Vaivart Puran which is another unscrupulous book like Bhavishya Puran that insults legends like Krishna and Ram. The concept of Radha grew popular only in very recent times during dark age of India when rulers of princely states were busy only in considering themselves Krishna incarnate and indulging into lustful activities by demeaning just a legendary Brahmachari character! Mahabharat does not contain these.
Please read this excellent article by Dr Satya Pal Singh, Police Commissioner of Police, Pune: Lord Krishna – Lord Krishna – an enlightening personality


POLYGAMY IN GENERAL

While polygamy was practiced by certain rulers at various points in time, it was restricted only to ruling class and never became a mainstream in larger population. That is why Hindus had no discomfort or objection to formal introduction of monogamy as a law after independence.

All the great legends of Hinduism, whom many consider to be near God, were purely monogamous or brahmachari- Vishnu, Shankar, Ram, Lakshman, Bharat, Shatrughna, Hanuman and Krishna.

Thus it is a gross myth that Hinduism accepts Polygamy.

On contrary, Vedas are unambiguous over recommendation of monogamy alone. The same has been the trend for general population and our role models.

If there is any philosophy that condemns polygamy and specifically demands monogamy, it is the Hindu Dharma based on noble precepts of Vedas.

Addendum:
On an additional note, I would like to address a few sophism that Dr Zakir Naik indulges into to justify polygamy:

1. Naik – Average life span of women is more than that of men.
By this logic, polyandry (one wife- multiple husband) should be allowed. Because, on average, one wife would require more than 1 husband to cover her entire life!

2. Naik – World female population is more than world male population.
This contradicts previous point. If one looks at 2008 data of World Population as published by UN Statistics Division, there are 2% more males than females in the world! The same is also true for marriageable age discarding children and elders. Does he recommend Polyandry now?

3. Before we get further, let us also look at the countries with worst gender ratio. You can view the list at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_sex_ratio
The table has facility to sort by fields. What we observe is that the top 9 countries with more men than women are all Muslim countries. Stricter the Islamic Law, more adverse the gender ratio. There are 2.74 times more men in UAE and 2.46 times in Qatar. India and Pakistan are also is not far off with their significant Muslim population!

4. Naik – Muslim women in due faith could bear a small personal loss to prevent a greater loss of letting other Muslim sisters becoming ‘public properties’.
We just saw the data above. Does Dr Naik recommend the inverse now?

5. In civilized societies like Vedic Dharma, each women apart from one’s wife is viewed as mother, by default. The basic rule is “Matrivat Paradaareshu – All except wife are like my mother”. That is why the question of someone becoming public property does not arise. In wars, legends like Shivaji would bow to imprisoned women and call them mother! And in a society that respects women, the question of adverse gender ratio does not arise as is happening in conservative Muslim countries.

6. What is important is use of word “property” for women. Dr Naik recommends that polygamy enables women to be private property rather than “public property” at small personal loss. This small loss is a great insult to entire womanhood. If sharing of husbands is haram, why is sharing of wife merely a small personal loss? Vedas do not discriminate at all between men and women and provide them equal rights and privileges in all matters including marriage.

Next he lists 4 reasons why polygamy is permitted but polyandry is not permitted:
a. This will help identify father of the child!
(But now we have DNA testing available!)
b. Man by nature is more polygamous!
(What is the proof for this except that polyandry is stoned to death? Is this not a ploy to insult entire womanhood by justifying polygamy?)
c. It is biologically difficult for women to be polyandrous and rear children!
(This is again another shameless reason to justify keeping multiple wives and concubines, in name of religion and social service!)
d. High chance of acquiring sexual disease!
(On contrary, medical science proves that it is women who are more susceptible to contract such diseases from polygamous men than vice versa. Being a medical student sometime, Dr Naik should have verified at least this much before publication. Or perhaps he never got a chance to practice or get back to medical books!)

Wise can decide themselves the mentality of this admirer of Osama bin Laden.

In summary, Polygamy is a malpractice, quite aptly condemned by the Vedas. Hinduism guided by Vedas and its role models has always emphasized on monogamy and self-control as the only way for humans.

Efforts to justify polygamy, through whatever reasons, is an insult to entire womanhood.

May such deviant minds introspect and come into the shade of Vedas. May they inculcate feeling of respect for entire Matru-Shakti.

This article is also available in Hindi at http://agniveer.com/4982/polygamy-hinduism-hi/

Facebook Comments

SHARE
Previous articleFAQ on Hinduism
Next articleDr Zakir Naik’s fraud exposed
Agniveer symbolizes the efforts of a soul marching towards the ultimate goal through destruction of ego and falsehood. With focus only on right knowledge, right actions and right devotion. In other words, Agniveer stands for compassion, character, tolerance and rational humanism. Agniveer believes in One World, One Humanity, One Family.

Join the debate

576 Comments on "Polygamy in Hinduism"

Notify of
avatar
500

karan chandra
3 years 9 months ago
http://www.islam-watch.org/MA_Khan/FarzanRapingSlave.htm [Q 70:29-30] And those who guard their private parts, Except in the case of their wives or those whom their right hands possess — for these surely are not to be blamed, [Q 4:3] If ye fear that ye shall not be able to deal justly with the orphans,… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
ALLAH KI HAISIYAT???- ye jo allah hai koi dimag ki soch hai,muhammad ki mind vision hai.jyada se jyada ye man tak hi chalang le pati hai.ALLAH JO HAI WO AACCHE SAPNE BHEJTA HAI AUR BURE SAPNE SHAITAN SE AATE HAI – aisa kahna hi dimag ka star ,mentality darshata hai.bahot… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@truth hater, maine pandit mahender pal arya k 15 questions k answers meinse eik post kara tha aur kaha tha ki MP ne claim kiya tha ki agar koi answer dedega to mein islam accept kar lunga phir kiyun islam accept nahi kiya……….. par tunmne kiya kara ki apni taraf… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
SATANIC VERSES KI SACCHAI – aaj tak satanic verses ki sacchai samne nahi aayi thi,pahli baar raj khul raha hai.sabhi budhimani logonko ye baat samaj me nahi aayi ki,jo aayate allah ke 3 beti,bete ka zikr karti hai,us me do ayte pahale thi aur bad me,nikali gayi.uska khulasa ki, wo… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@truth hater, sabse bari baat yeh ki jo points tum utha rahe ho yeh so called pandit ji k hain hi nahin? ya to yeh uske question mein hote aur answer na diya gaya hota tab to tumhari baat thikthi lekin tum to naye points le aaye to iska matlab… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@truth hater, your mistake no 6 whichis pending to refute. —गलती ६. आप कहते हैं कि “अज़ाजील को नाम बताए बिना पुछा जाना कि अगर तुम सत्यवादी हो तो सभी चीज़ों के नाम बताओ” आपक कृपया ये कुरान से प्रमाण दीजिये कि इब्लीस (आपका अज़ाजील) को कहाँ पुछा नाम बताओ?… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@truth hater, adam alaihissalam ko kaun kaun se naam bataye gaye humein nahi pata par explain to kiya hai na ki //गलती ४. ये आप ने ठीक कहा की अल्लाह ने आदम को सारी वस्तुओं के नाम बताए. लेकिन आपत्ति करने से पहले इसका अर्थ तो समझ लेते. ‘वस्तुओं के… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
GP see the standard of your arya mahendra paal …kitna jhut likhta hai yeh aadmi ..see the question asked by mahendrapal and answer by islamhinduismdotcomप्रश्न २ उत्तर पंडित जी आपके दुसरे प्रश्न में भी काफी गलतियाँ हैं| गलती १. फरिश्तों ने मिटटी लाने से मना किया. इस का कोई प्रमाण… Read more »
Truth Seeker
Truth Seeker
3 years 9 months ago
@anti-agniveer Why are you engaged in such stupid refutations? This does not serve any purpose. We are aware Islam is evil on the name of religion. In Islam nothing knowledgeable but fairly tales of angles, virgins, Jinn etc. Now soleve my queries. __________आप ने ठीक कहा की अल्लाह ने आदम… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@truth hater, sabse bari baat yeh ki jo points tum utha rahe ho yeh so called pandit ji k hain hi nahin? ya to yeh uske question mein hote aur answer na diya gaya hota tab to tumhari baat thikthi lekin tum to naye points le aaye to iska matlab… Read more »
Truth Seeker
Truth Seeker
3 years 9 months ago
@anti-agniveer I do not compare my self with Pandit Ji & I do not know him also. But I can refute anyone. No Muslim have dare to debate with me. Do you have? If you refute me I will accept Islam with my whole family & will preach Islam. ____आप… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@truth hater, tabhi to main tujhe truth hater kehta hun kiyunki tujhe pata hai ki upar ythaye gaye points par tu kuch nahi bol sakta is liye tune sire se mana hi kar diya ki tu Mahendar pal arya ko nahi janta? aryasamaj ka bachca bacha janta hai mahendar pal… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@Truth hater, why are u in so much hurry to refute the answer? you should start refuting from first point.. गलती १. फरिश्तों ने मिटटी लाने से मना किया. इस का कोई प्रमाण कुरआन से दीजिए. गलती २. ये ‘अजाजील’ नाम आप कहाँ से ले आये? कुरआन में इब्लीस का… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
@Anti agniveer ji, jab param adarniy shri iblees ji farishto me se nahi the to farishto ko diye gaye kurani allah ka adesh uspar lagu bhi kaise ho sakte the? fir iblees ji ke viruddh sizda n karne ki tohamat kurani allah ne kyo lagayi ? iblees ko kuranialalah ne… Read more »
Truth Seeker
Truth Seeker
3 years 9 months ago

@anti-agniveer
Are you coward, stupid because you are writing your self anti – agniveer
Agniveer means Bravo, Best.
अयं अग्निर्वीरतमो (यजुर्वेद १५.५२) I am Agniveer. I am the Best.

anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago

@truth hater, are you fool? if some stupid claim himself “I am Mahendrapal arya, I am the best” then any one rejecting his false claim wil become coward?

yajurveda can be standard for you but it is not standard for me.

anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@GP, you have written //See dear, Scientific laws doesnot change// you are saying that scientific laws do not change and talking about evolution “THEORY”??? can u not understand difference between theory and LAWS??? can you tell me which evolution theory is unequivocally accepted by the scientists only? and which evolution… Read more »
abhi
abhi
3 years 9 months ago

Dear friends

yeh ek bahut hi aacha blog hai jaha hum kuch discuss kar sakte hai so i request all of you to give respesct to each other and have guts to accept the truth………

jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
ISLAM KI SACCHAI 9 – islam ka arth peace nahi hai,nahi tha aur nahi rahega.islam ka arth hai sharanagati.kuch akal ke diwane jaise batate hai islam=peace bebunuyad aur sabse bada jhuth hai.Islam=Submission,Salam=Well-being/Peace,(Derivation of Salama=The stinging of a snake or the tanning of theleather,Saleema=To be saved or to escape from danger(when… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@antiagniveer,tera dimag kaam nahi kar raha kya?? dimag zara hosh se bhar phir dekh…hahaha….tu abhi bhi ”hai” ke zol se waqib nahi hua..hahaha..”hai” ke zol me rahna hi to vedanti bhram kahate hai,aur tu usi me uljha hai.hahaha…..muze koi bhi chiz bata jo ‘hai’ ??? Agar tuze koi chiz ‘hai’… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago

@”lage raho shankar bhai” laffazi koi tumse sikhe… kabhi apni aane wali generation ko apne comment parhana kiyunki mujhe ummedhai voh ved ved ka chakkar chor chukein hongein aur kisi ache school se education leingein aur phir bataeinge ki “zol” kahan hai .. hahaha
byeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@antiagniveer,dimag me hosh aa gaya kya?hahaha…tu abhi bhi ”hai” ke zol se wakib nahi hua.tune hosh ki baat kari hai is liye batata hu.do sentence hai tere samne ab tu hi tay kar ki kisme ”hai” hai.kyoki jab mai hai lagaunga to tu fir ved ke eswar ko lagayega,is se… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@lage raho shankar bhai, kya jawab diya hai.. wah maza aagaya… kardi na vedanti wali baat..hahahaha bahut maza aagaya.. zara apna purana comment parhna.. kiya tumne yeh nahi likha ki woh mahan se bhi mahan hai???? aur jab maine hai par sawal kiya to kaha ki //aanu se anu aur… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
ISLAM KI SACCHAI 8 – The prophet of Islam committed SHIRK – he was a hypocrite – he made himself Allah’s partner! Read carefully…. O you who believe, obey Allah and His Messenger … ” (8:20) “Say: obey Allah and obey the Messenger … ” (24:54) … “Obey Allah and… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
ISLAM KI SACCHAI 7-Then Allah’s Apostle returned with the Inspiration, his neck muscles twitching with terror till he entered upon Khadija and said, “Cover me! Cover me!” They covered him till his fear was over and then he said, “O Khadija, what is wrong with me?” Then he told her… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
jab aadmi sapna dekhta hai,tab wo aapne bhitar pura jagat nirmit karta hai.jaisa jagat bahar hota hai vaise hi bhitar hota hai.bahar,chand,suraj,aakash,zamin,diwar achal hai to us ke sapne me bhi wo achal hote hai.is ka arth hua wo jo duniya banata hai wo apni man ki shakti se banata hai.koi… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@pagal-shankar, main isse zyada kiya kehsakta hun ki “Lage raho shankar BHAI” tum koi pagal type aadmi ho jo apni baton ke antarvirodh ko nahi dekh parah.. kuch dikhata hun jab humne kaha ki Allah mahan hai to tumne kaha ki agar “hai” lagaoge to present tense hoga aur uska… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@antiagniveer,aapni philosophy par sharm mahsus kar rahe ho.hahaha…hindu jab tahakikat karta hai tab sab tarike apnata hai.islam ki philosophy ALLAH ke irdgird ghumti hai,isliye allah ki tahakikat karna hi islam ki philosophy hai.kyo ghabra raha hai???hum to eswar ki tahkikat me nahi ghabrate.hahaha..hindu ki sary philosophy drasta yane dekhanewale ki… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@GP You reminds me that the children Adam & Eve were get married among themselves this was because to increase the human population, to full fill this necessity He made this law, the purpose was just to increase the human population but later on this law was changed by Allah… Read more »
GP
3 years 9 months ago
@Maria. Dear Sis, giving response doesnt means that u r giving answer to the question….. 1)Initially when I said Allah allows incest then you said “FALSE CHARGE! Allah DOESN’T allow it IN ANY WAY. Give proof from QUR’AN, Hurry up now!” but when I shows it then u make a… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@GP You typed about Vedas – Veda is not a religious book & according to Vedic God Relgion is not Important , there is no hell paradise, it is not important that in which sect a person is – The basic requirement is one should b pious, this is Vedic… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@GP Your words: “Above in one post u also mocked one Christian gentleman over Abhraham having sex with daughters but I think ur Allah allows it….So u indulge in sin by mocking at allah rules”. Re: I just showed him what does his bible say regarding the attributes of Prophets.… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@GP “I never told that I agree/disagree with Darwin evolution.” Re: But still u r trying to convince me my religion is flawed by Evolution Theory – Absurd/dnot make any sense! ” to prove ur point u also copy pasted from some where for giving an impression.” Re; To my… Read more »
GP
3 years 9 months ago
@Maria Your words: “I just showed him what does his bible say regarding the attributes of Prophets. …………. One can analyse any text.” Re: Abhrahamic story is also part of Quranic history… So if u think that is wrong then that applies to Quran also…. By showing him what u… Read more »
Jay
Jay
3 years 9 months ago
Here is an explanation of “theory” in science “A scientific theory is “a well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world, based on a body of facts that have been repeatedly confirmed through observation and experiment.”[1][2] Scientists create scientific theories from hypotheses that have been corroborated through the scientific… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Jay “A common misconception is that scientific theories are rudimentary ideas that will eventually graduate into scientific laws when enough data and evidence has been accumulated. A theory does not change into a scientific law with the accumulation of new or better evidence. A theory will always remain a theory;… Read more »
Jay
Jay
3 years 9 months ago
The assumption is by believers of this or that faith. One Middle Eastern ethnic group, the Jews, had their own creation myth of Adam and Eve, and Judaism’s two Jewish religious offshoots, Christianity and Islam retained Judaism’s creation myths. Everyone look at the link posted above and read the different… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Jay Sorry I made blunders in hurry so I rephrase again my question: Maybe you have more knowledge about Science so tell me can a theory never b falsified as scientific law? One more question: As per Darwinist Theory of Evolution organism might evolve through time, with one type of… Read more »
Jay
Jay
3 years 9 months ago

The answer is in the description already posted. Reread what is scientific theory and what is scientific law. They are two different concepts.

As for evolution, it is on going.

Jay
Jay
3 years 9 months ago

I would suggest that people read about the Theory of Evolution themselves. Here is a start http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution

Jay
Jay
3 years 9 months ago
Adam and Eve were Middle Eastern Jewish mythology characters on the origins of the humans. Islam is the Arab version of Judaism so copied the Jewish creation myths. Every ethnic group that had their own religion had their own stories on how the human race came to be. Here is… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
kurani allah pagal hai ya ” moodi” ? jab mood bana sansar bana diya atma [rooh] banadi adam bana diya adam se havva bana di fir bhul ko sudhar diya ab nari se nar paida kiye jate hai fir mood bana sage bhai -bahano me sex karva diya fir sudhar… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@SDC Your words: “Just wanted to say this: When you are in the field of comparative religion, you should get used to such abuses. Abuses have been hurled at our idols as well. I do not think you have any claim to any higher moral ground in this respect.” Re:… Read more »
SDC
SDC
3 years 9 months ago

Are you also against grave worship?

Anyways, there are others of your ilk who indulge in mocking other faiths, and you have to answer them in a befitting manner.

jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@antiagniveer, kyo bhanbhana rahe ho??? Dimag ke andar tare chamak gaye kya??” islam ki philosophy allah ke irdgird ghumti hai.allah ki tahkikat karna hi philosophy hai.tu us se kyo ghabra raha hai? hahaha.Tune kabhi aapne ko dekha hai?? Tu kahega ha,aankh se.par jab tu aankh band karega tab dekhna band… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@antiagniveer,abe akal ke gadhe,hahaha..ved kabhi bhi dekhne ko nahi kahte aur na hi manane ko kahte. khojo aur jano ye kahte.unka sara jor JANANE par hai..manane par nahi.wo bhitar dekhane ko kahte hai.aur tu bahar ko hi dekhne ko dekhna kah raha hai. Bhitar dekh to tuze bhi dekhai padega.hahaha,ALLAH… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Anti Agniveer :Request you to please don’t reply back to the hate mongers like “jai shankar & “raj.hyd”. What Jai shankar typed in his last post is just a red rag to a bull. The more you will reply more he will use irrational absurd language by mocking ridiculing, for… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@anti agniveer,tu sharm se pani pani kyo ho raha hai..ha.ha.ha…tu kahta hai ved ka eshwar dikhai nahi padta ? ha.ha.ha…meri baat siddha karne se pahale tere allah ko dekte hai.allah ek false concept hai,.kaise ??allah kitana mahan hai ye nahi pata??uski mahanta kaha se shuru hoti hai??akash,,prithvi ya satve aasman… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@maria,you are thought is completly crime..because none of allah himself understand his world only muslims,.none of muhammad himself understand his world only muslims. HE COMPLETY THINKING OTHERS…WHY????his thinking is based only others.you say my world is roundup quran-allah-muhammad.it is a complete mental phenomenon.because truth is everywhere and same.but you say… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@jai shankar Again a clumsy whimsical rhetorical response to my rational post. You are insulting my faith. You are also insulting me by saying I’m narrow minded & I’ve a criminal mind – I have a courage to digest . Look at yourself what you’re ? You’re believing in Veda… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@maria,your mind is very low level,you are narrow minded.your world only roundup in quran-allah-muhammad.you leave1400 years ago.your born here but mind is 1400years old back.peace is only peace he does not need quran.peace is a inner state of mind.without quran peace is exists.quran is a barier of peace.all kinds of… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@jai shanker Hothead! What I can say after reading your clumsy whimsical rhetorical post is; Your words: “your mind is very low level,you are narrow minded. your world only roundup in quran-allah-muhammad.” Re: Yeah! T a “T”! You’re exactly right my world is around my Qur’an, my beloved Allah &… Read more »
SDC
SDC
3 years 9 months ago
No Maria, you should no longer stay in this material world. You should rather proceed to jannah, the world of your Allah, at the earliest. Peace can exist even without religion. It is verily a state of mind as JS has rightly pointed out. You may not be afraid but… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@SDC, i think you have some confusion in understanding faith. can u abuse gurugranth sahib infront of any sikh? even u cant touch gurugranthsahib. can u dare to touch gurugranth sahib? we always give non muslims translations of quran and we always welcome questions on islam but we cant tolerate… Read more »
SDC
SDC
3 years 9 months ago
Yes, if one is a daee in India like Zakir Naik or a fanatic like Akbaruddin Owaisi, he can even abuse Hinduism followed by the majority and get away with it. You cannot tolerate abuses for Allah and rasool but you have the right to abuse others’ beliefs? Just needed… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@raj.hyd (Other hatemongers should too read this passage): In response to your two previous posts. You used cheep filthy words for my beloved Prophet (pbuh) is just disgusting but I have to sequester it because Quran say so ==>”So bear with patience all that they(non-believers) say”(50:39). Allah has already told… Read more »
SDC
SDC
3 years 9 months ago

Just wanted to say this: When you are in the field of comparative religion, you should get used to such abuses. Abuses have been hurled at our idols as well. I do not think you have any claim to any higher moral ground in this respect.

Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@GP You typed so many things. What did Roshingyas do, I don’t know, this is first time I’ve listened his name & what you typed about paki, Bangladeshi blah,blah,blah I can say anyone whether one is a Muslim or non Muslim, has no right to shed blood unjustly. What I’m… Read more »
GP
3 years 9 months ago

@maria
See the plight of Hindus from ur so called peace loving Islamic state….

http://zeenews.india.com/news/nation/more-pak-hindus-arrive-in-india-say-wont-return_793407.html

Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@GP Your words: “How can that religion be true where Allah allowed Father to have sex with daughter,,, Mother with sons,,, Brother with sister…. Such disgusting Allah can never be true god ” Re: FALSE CHARGE! Allah DOESN’T allow it IN ANY WAY. Give proof from QUR’AN, Hurry up now!… Read more »
GP
3 years 9 months ago
@ Maria….. Sometime it is better to use logic instead mugging word by word.. As per Abhrahmic belief , First God has created Adam and Eve and then all of us come from this two pair…. So we all are brothers & sister’s(adam ke bacche)…. But wait one second ,… Read more »
GP
3 years 9 months ago
@Maria Here I given ur comment in inverted coma and my reply follows: “You typed so many things. What did Roshingyas do, I don’t know, this is first time I’ve listened his name”. (REPLY) “After discussing whole Quran, u r asking who is Mohammad”..Rohingyas are the Bangladeshi muslim ILLIGALLY settled… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago

@maria,you don’t understand peace.I help you,read jejus,read goutam buddha,read mahaveer,read all saints of vaishnvas,read vedantik acharyas.only his act peace. hands are empty,no use sword.only fear and haterated mind accept swords.muhammads hand sword means kill all others.sword does not spreads peace. only peaceful mind goes spread peace.

Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@jai shankar I think I understand what does “peace” really mean. Thanks I need not to read others book to understand the meaning of peace sorry. Go look at history you’d know how ignorant /unjust fighters the Mushreen of that time were, they thyself wanted war therefore Prophet (PBUH) &… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
mariya ji kuran5/51 aur 5/57 bhi dekh lijiye jisme kurani allah muslimo ko isai v yahudi se dosti karne korokta hai yahkurani allah ka parspar virodhi adesh kyo hai ? AAJ KI KURAN BETARTEEB HAI ISLIYE APKO BHI SAMAJHNE ME TAKLIF HOTI HAI ? jab muhammad ji kamjor the tab… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@maria, what is meaning of,peaceful??can you undersatnd peaceful carefully??? peaceful mind does not understand fights.peace is a mind condition all thoughts are go down,he don’t understand who enemy and who friend.only peace is exists.allah himself does not understand peace.he Haterated jews and Isais,unbelievers.why you dont understand peace? Your defination of… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago

@GP

*Edit*
Jihad cannot b done *not* only in battle field but it can *also* be *done* everywhere whenever someone try to shed blood of Muslims unjustly.

GP
3 years 9 months ago
U said many thing but means nothing….. First of all Rohingyas are not citizen of Burma but of Bangladesh… and bangladesh already got freedom from Pakistan… The height is that u are mentioning them freedom fighter…. from whom… it is not their country and ur so called muslim bangladesh rejected… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@GP, this post seems to be Maria but i am sorry to interrupt, 1)from ur comment i conclude that P stands for Pandey??? 2)there are so many bhutani living India and they have many facilities for business then y are u not fighting for them? no rohingyas raped any woman… Read more »
GP
3 years 9 months ago
@anti agniveer Your name only suggest that you will speak negative only….. Arey bhai kam se kam naam tho teek rakte… 1)Didn’t get what u mean to say or concluded… 2) Bhuthani leaving in India illegally…. I dont thik so… Even if they did I dont think they are indulging… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@GP Jihad cannot b done only in battle field but it can be everywhere whenever someone try to shed blood of Muslims unjustly. In Burma Innocent Muslims are killed by Budhisht non Muslims . Moreover What about the innocent Muslims 106 000 documented civilian death in Iraq by American Soldiers,… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@anti agniveer,jab muhammad battle kar rahe the,to wo kya peaceful the?? kisi ke birthday par koi pahuche aur apni talwar uske gardan par rakh ke kahe ki ”happy birth day tu you” aur koi guldaste ,gift liye pahuche aur kahe ki happy birth day tu you to tum kisko sahi… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
jab muahmmad ji kamjor the tab vah shanti ki bat karte the! vah sex ke bhukhe the isliye unka apne samudayo se vivad tha! jab kisi ki kanya ko sex ki nigah se dekhoge , tab malom hone par vivad to hoga hi ! muahammad ji ko do hio to… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Jai shankar Careful hothead! I can sense your hatred. Your are seeming like a most hateful person. All over I get by reading your whimsical post is ‘you cannot understand English completely therefore you didn’t get what I posted’. So read the Urdu replies of another Muslim brother, maybe you… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@anti agniveer,iska matlab pani,tum sharm se pani pani ho rahe ho kya??ya dimag ice jaisa jam gaya hai kya??? ye true muslim ne kaha ki allah everywhere hai.ha.ha…ab agar wo everywheare hai,to barma ke logon me ghus gaya hoga.aur agar everywhere nahi hai above earth hai,sky hai to tamasha kyo… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@maria,kyo wrong defence kar rahi ho,battle me tum kisi ka bhi katl kar sakte ho??? Allah aisa kahta hai??is ka matalab kya sab all musalman battal ke ground me khade hai kya???koi bhi ‘batal’ki aad me hatya kare to kya wo hatyara nahi hoga kya?to tumara dimag kharab hai??ye muhammad… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@pagal-shankar, sabse zyada to peace ka zikr budhuon mein hai to phir dekha tumne burma main yeh peace lower kiya kar rahe hain? aur islam k acoording jo lare use maro aur jo hathiyar daal de use mat maro aisa hai. aur jo tum pagal ki bakwas kar rahe ho… Read more »
Truth Seeker is against rapist prophets Mohammed
Truth Seeker is against rapist prophets Mohammed
3 years 9 months ago

@anti-agniveer
Bhai anti-agniveer Islamic nam nahi hai. Kripaya kaffiro ke nam v riti-rivajo ko copy na karo.

raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
jo apna nam bhi nahi likh pate hai vah islam ki shiksha de bada ajeeb lagta hai ! aaj vah apna arbii nam jan bijhkar chod rahe hao kal ko vah islam ko chod sakte hai ! yah to matr ek shuruat hai ! jara jain samuday bhi dekh lijiye… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@pagal-raj, tum log kitne kharab dil k log ho. kiya tum news parhte? wahan total safaya ho rahahai aur zulm ho raha hai aur tuam samarthan kar rahe ho? agar koi tumhare ghar ki aurat ka rape karde to kiya tum bhi rape karoge? yeh bhi to zulm hoga. hum… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
@anti agniveer, hamne kab varma ki hinsa ka samarthan kiya hai jakar dekhiye siriya me uske pahale libiya me muslim hi muslim ki hatya kar rahe the ! aj har hafte 2000′[ do hajar ] muslimo ki hatya siriya me ho rahi hai muslim chuop kyo hai ? irak me… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@raj.hyd You point out three verses , iIll explain them. ==>O Ye who believe! fight the infidels who are near unto you, and surely let them find in you sternness, and know that Allah is with the God-fearing, (9:123) Explanation: This verse is about the fighting in battle-field or with… Read more »
GP
3 years 9 months ago
Hi Maria, Didn’t want to come in between but could not help it… Just want to add….. For ur kind info Rohingyas are not citizen of Burma.. They illegally come and settle there.. Burma dont consider them as their citizen… Then as per ur logic given above If Burmese buddhist… Read more »
anti-agniveer
anti-agniveer
3 years 9 months ago
@budhism hinduon ka eik part hai, hindu apni counting barhane k liye budhuon ko bhi hindu mante hain. bodh dharam apne aap ko ahinsa/non-violence ka mazhab batlata hai aur burma main aurto ka rape karna logon ko zinda jalana aam baat hai. rohingiye musalman mehnat kush mazdoor hain jo ki… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
124000 kalpit nabi rasool manne vale , faishto v jinno ki fauj ko manne vale , huro aur gilmo ki fauj ko manne vale 73 firko me islam bant jayega iska anuman lagane vale muhammad ji kya isko ek hi majahaba kaha jayega hamare pas to 315 fir ko me… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Truth seeker Prophet (PBUH) said kill the non-believers wherever you found them in battle field. Your words: killing of women and children also legitimate if they belong from kaffirs/non-believer as per prophet of Islam. Re: False charge! It is narrated by Ibn ‘Umar that a woman was found killed in… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago

@ Mariya ji kuran kitni ajeeb kitab hai? ap kuran se apne paksh me achhi ayate bhi pesh kar leti hai aur hamko bhi kuran ki gandi ayte bhi mil jati hai jo manvta ke viruddh hoti hai itni paraspar virodhi bate kuran me kyo hai ?

True Muslim
True Muslim
3 years 9 months ago
Raj.hyd…Allah Pak ney challenge kia tha kaafon ko k agar tm Quran ko galat samjty ho tau sirf aik aisa chapter bnao…..Allah ye kehtay hai 2/22 keh .”And if you (Arab pagans, Jews, and Christians) are in doubt concerning that which We have sent down (i.e. the Qur’an) to Our… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@maria,kyo jhuti tasalli de rahi ho..man ki suraksha kar ke Truth se nahi bach sakti. Satya akhir satya hota hi hai.tum kahti ho mai kisi bhi faith ka insult nahi karti aur koi muslim wrong hai to allah dojakh ki aag me dalega to.yahi to hum nahi chahte ki tum… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@jai shankar As my native language is Urdu not Hindi, the words of yours I didn’t make understand “suraksha” & “Satya akhir satya hota hi hai”. However, I get all over what you said. You say that you Vedanti r more peaceful. yes there’re but NOT all. I have seen… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
@ mariya ….ji yah jo apne kutran ki anaram ayte pesh ki hai vamakki ayte hai jio kuran ki any ayto se radd ho chuki hai jara kuran ki garam ayte bhi dekh lijiye dekhe kuran 9/123 jisme kurani allah muslimo se kahate hai ki apne aspas ke gairmuslimo se… Read more »
True Muslim
True Muslim
3 years 9 months ago
Haan aap ney sahi quote kya hai lakin aap sirf ayaat uthatey hai jo context kay bahir hota hai aur dosron ko bhadka rahay hai tau aap ki galat femi hai k hm bhadkay gaen kyun hum saidhay raastay par hain…… Allah apnay bandon ki hamesha madad karta hai is… Read more »
raj.hyd
raj.hyd
3 years 9 months ago
@true muslim, jab kuran hi betarteeb hai to fir hamko kyo dosh de rahe hai? jis ayat ka hamne sabut diya hai vah kyo muslimo ke liye pesh ki gayi ? kurani allah to muhhamd ji ko santan dekar bhi unki ankho ke samne chhin leta hai ! batlaiye kurani… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@TRUE MUSLIM,wa bhai kya khub baat kahi?? Ye kaise sabit hoga ki allah zinda bhi ya murda bhi hai? Agar tum usko zinda kahte ho to kaha jivan bita raha,jee kaha raha hai???sanse kaha le raha hai??ab jab jinda hai to uska food kya hai???wo jivan kis stan me bita… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@rsdfgg,pagalonme awwal,tu pahale apne chitt ko saf kar,shudh kar sab vishwas se mukt ho ja swikar kar ki allah ek mithak hai,false concept hai,muhammad ki dimagi soch hai.fir tuze mai ved ka gyan dunga….ha.ha.ha..bina allah ka vichar liye ved ka gyan nahi mil sakta tu quran chod .ved ka eshwar… Read more »
Javed
Javed
3 years 9 months ago

All hindus out here,
i apologise sincerely for my previous comments how i talked about your religion,.
also i apologise on behalf of all those who did the same,.
i will not add much, only that we respect your beliefs, onto you your religion and onto me mine.

abhi
abhi
3 years 9 months ago

good i real thought………….

Raj
Raj
3 years 9 months ago
My dear friend Javed, I only read hate comments on various sites especialy between Hindu and Muslims and never ever said anything to anybody. You are the only one whom I talking to regarding this, We as Hindu or Sanatan or more precisly as human being sees God in every… Read more »
hinduagnostic
hinduagnostic
3 years 9 months ago

we can do that we are not attacking islam only trying to remove lies made by others about our religion

Maria (IslamicDefence)
Maria (IslamicDefence)
3 years 9 months ago
@hinduagnostic Your words; “we can do that we are not attacking islam only trying to remove lies made by others about our religion.” Re; Really? Maybe you are the doing so. But all Hindus don’t do so. They just mock Islam. Yet we Muslims are trying to remove misconceptions about… Read more »
SDC
SDC
3 years 9 months ago

Now, Maria whether you have realized it or not but you already have insulted our faith. Your superficial concern for us being roasted in hell fire for supposedly following satanic (Hindu) beliefs tantamount to an indirect affront to all practicing Hindus.

SDC
SDC
3 years 9 months ago
Then in that case, why do you object to others calling Mohammad a rapist, pedophile, and looter based on his actions? And, why do you have to address them as hatemongers and his teachings not worthy of emulation? At least, an atheist will be far better than a muslim as… Read more »
SDC
SDC
3 years 9 months ago
Then in that case, why do you object to others calling Mohammad a rapist, pedophile, and looter based on his actions? And, why do you have to address them as hatemongers and his teachings not worthy of emulation? At least, an atheist will be far better than a muslim as… Read more »
Truth Seeker
Truth Seeker
3 years 9 months ago

@Maria
Prophet said kill the non-believers wherever you found them and killing of women and children also legitimate if they belong from kaffirs/non-believer as per prophet of Islam.

SDC
SDC
3 years 9 months ago

“We are helping non-Muslims because we are worry for them that if they don’t accept the truth they would have to roasted in Hell-Fire!”

So, you mean to say their beliefs are false. Is this not an insult?

Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@SDC Nah! This is not an insult in any way when I say your belief is wrong. Do you mean to say you’re Insulting by taking my belief as wrong? If you’re insulting others then Y r u trying to convince me to not insult others? Or do you mean… Read more »
Maria (IslamicDefence)
Maria (IslamicDefence)
3 years 9 months ago
@SDC I didn’t insulted your faith. Bring here my statements through which i insulted. What I said it’s just my belief. According to my faith if any Muslim will do wrong he would also have to be roasted in Hell-Fire. Quran teaches me “dont insult others faith”. I’m not Insulting… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Ankur Verse: “say we believe in Allah and that which hath been sent down unto us and that which was sent down unto Ibrahim and Ismail and Ishaq and Yaqub and the tribes,and that which was given to Musa and lsa, and that which was given to the (other) prophets… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
Adan jo hai wo bahut hi miss-understanding se bhari hai.Allahu Akbar -god is great matlab allah mahan hai.ye sabit karta hai ki allah mahan pahle nahi tha ab mahan hai.ex.deta hu taki samaj me aasani hogi, jab hum chote bachhe ko jab bada hua to kahte hai aadmi hua ab… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@jai shankar (fake id banane wala),manushya yudh karta hai to wo bahar ke khshetra me jeet jata hoga par aksar ye paya jaata hai ke wo antas ke khshetra me hara hua hi paya jata hai, sikandar mahan bahar to jeeta par bhiter ki ladai wo haar gaya, jaate waqt… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Qul huwa Allahu ahad Assalamualaikum. Why did you addressed me by using Ankur’s name? Islam wants us to be honest at least – Avoid to do such which can create a bad Impression about Islam – Can we tell a lie while doing dawah? Allah doesn’t allow it brother! And… Read more »
Ankur
Ankur
3 years 9 months ago
@Maria IslamicDefence: Thats the way to go…A suggestion though you didint ask, one must live this life in the pursuit of the ultimate truth, keep on acquiring knowledge and rejecting falsehood based on logic and critical thought, take nothing at its face value, be always critical of everything that is… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Ankur Agreed. But when someone pick out a verse from Qur’an & say it’s illogical, I start searching, start gaining knowledge & sooner or later ultimately the Qur’an wins. As I said my knowledge isn’t enough so often I fail to prove somethings then I often think this is my… Read more »
Qul Hua Allah hu Ahad
Qul Hua Allah hu Ahad
3 years 9 months ago

@maria, just read my reply here ..
http://satyagni.com/islam-and-hinduism-debate/#comment-58691
please read..

Ankur
Ankur
3 years 9 months ago
@Maria IslamicDefence : Very nice to read you words 🙂 No doubt that the Almighty renders his help(in the ways you understand) to you when you ask with the true heart. but that has noting to do with the Quran or the prophet of Islam.The kind of experience that you… Read more »
Ankur
Ankur
3 years 9 months ago
@Maria IslamicDefence :[knew you would need some additiona help 🙂 ] Regarding 7:11 we are back to square One, that question that i asked initially and you responsed with the logic of “Adam being a magnificient creation…”, so here it is Again why would Allah Order XYZ to bow to… Read more »
Maria IslamicDefence
Maria IslamicDefence
3 years 9 months ago
@Ankur Case-1- Your words: “Regarding 7:1 if the Angels thought that Allah’s creation was so magnificent,they should certainly have bowed to Allah instead of his creation “Adam” , Analogy; when Edison created/invented the light bulb , people gave him respect and acknowledged him for his greatness rather than showing respect… Read more »
rami
rami
3 years 9 months ago

lol.. the wikipedia list u provided doe not say its muslim countries in the top..
It is just in Alphabetical order 😀

“Let’s not oppose just for the sake of opposing”

Peace!!

jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
@truth seekar, ek doha jo bahut kuch kahta hai, “BUND” SAMANA SAMUND ME,HERAT HERAT HE SAKHI RAHYA KABIR HERAI. Ye sadharan chit ki awastha hai, par jaise Vishwas mukta hota hai chit to ye hota hai,”SAMUND” SAMANA BUND ME,HERAT HERAT HE SAKHI RAHYA KABIR HERAI. Pahle to main aapko ek… Read more »
Truth Seeker
Truth Seeker
3 years 9 months ago
@jaishankir, kiya tum bata sakte ho ki tum kis Ishwar mein vishwas rakhte ho aur rakhte bhi ho ya nahi? kiya shiv,vishnu aur brahma ki trinity/trishool mein wishvas rakhte ho? agar tum koi baat manoge hi nahi to kisi ko bhi hara doge tum to kehdoge mere paas koi praman… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
dr.zakir naik sach me agar vad-vivad karna chahta hai to use main hara sakta hu..dekho agar praman ki baat aayegi to pratyaksha,aanuman,aagam ye 3praman mukhya hote hai. Ab dekho islam ke paas pratyakshya praman allah ka nahi hai.allah ko kisi ne pratykshy nahi dekha khud muhammad ne bhi nahi dekha.is… Read more »
jai shankar
jai shankar
3 years 9 months ago
islam ki original teaching kho gai hai .thodi thodi ved ke vichar jaha nirgun,shunya,koi aakar nahi ,koi sathidar nahi,keval wo hi hai, ye teaching corrupt ho gai hai.kyo ki har bachha hindu paida hota hai.kaise suno. Jab baccha ma ke pet me hota hai tab uske chitta par koi akar… Read more »
Qul huwa Allahu ahad
Qul huwa Allahu ahad
3 years 9 months ago
@Maria, i think that you belong to another country so u dont know about Hindus and Hinduism. i am Indian I have a wide experience about Dawah in Hindus. I have talked about islam with almost every friend. I have gifted and sold many books in Hindi, Urdu, and English… Read more »
Ankur
Ankur
3 years 9 months ago
@Qul huwa Allahu ahad:Hope you are getting paid well for propagating Quran 4 rishis were inspired and received vedas knowledge in a new language known as sanskrit This statement is a copy paste of all that you know , and now i know who tried an identity theft 🙂 poor… Read more »
Qul huwa Allahu ahad
Qul huwa Allahu ahad
3 years 9 months ago
@ankur, you are right i have been paid unlimited reward for the propagation of Quran and i know that you know who is paying and will pay in hereafter. it is hindus who always seek money for everything whenever go to temple they pay some amount to the priest/pandit of… Read more »
Ankur
Ankur
3 years 9 months ago
@Qul huwa Allahu ahad: I just hope that you are not dissapointed once this life is over. Now that i know you have read satyapraksh, why dont you logically refute the claims rather than spending effort on distrubiting the Uthaman’s Quran. well there had to be a first language and… Read more »
wpDiscuz